Christianity has some of the most bizarre, internally contradictory, and frankly unhinged beliefs of any major religion on earth. And most Christians have never stopped to think about how strange they actually sound. I spent 24 years of my life believing this stuff. I defended it. I preached it. So I get it. I'm not saying anyone is dumb for believing this stuff, but I want to reexamine it in a way that maybe we haven't thought of before.
We're going to be putting seven of the strangest core beliefs in Christianity under a microscope. Doctrines taught in mainstream churches to millions of people. We're going straight to the Bible, church councils, and the actual doctrines themselves. And by the end, I think you'll agree that if any of these were presented to you cold for the first time as an adult, you would laugh the person presenting them out of the room.
Let's start with the one that you may not have realized wasn't metaphorical:
1. You Are Eating God
Every single Sunday, hundreds of millions of Christians participate in communion. They eat a little wafer and wash it down with some wine or grape juice to symbolize the body and blood of Jesus. Sounds like just a harmless ritual, right? Except that for Catholic and Orthodox Christians, it's not symbolic at all. They believe that the bread and wine literally physically transform into the actual flesh and blood of Jesus Christ.
This doctrine is called transubstantiation, and the Catholic Church has held to it since the Fourth Lateran Council in 1215. The biblical basis? Well, Jesus himself says in John 6:53 that unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you. And at the Last Supper, he said, "This is my body and this is my blood." So according to over a billion Catholics, every single Sunday, the communion wafer stops being bread and becomes the literal meat of a 2,000-year-old Jewish carpenter. Still looks like bread, still tastes like bread. It still has the exact molecular composition of bread, but it's not bread anymore. It's Jesus.
Early Romans actually accused Christians of cannibalism because of this belief. And honestly, can you blame them? If someone told you that they were meeting up this week with their friends to ritualistically consume human flesh and blood, you'd probably want to check their basement.
Protestants, to their credit, mostly treat it as symbolic. But the fact that the largest Christian denomination on Earth officially teaches that you are chewing on God's body every week should probably come up more in conversation.
2. God Is Three People Who Are Also One Person
God is the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. Three distinct people, but also one God. Not three gods, one God in three persons who are each fully God, but there's only one of them. If it sounds like a contradiction, that's because it is. And the Bible never actually explains it.
The word "Trinity" doesn't appear anywhere in the scriptures. Early Christians kind of cobbled it together from scattered verses. John 1:1 says that Jesus is God. 1 Corinthians 8:6 says that the Father is God. Acts 5 implies that the Holy Spirit is God. And Deuteronomy insists that there's only one God. This led to centuries of vicious infighting, excommunications, and even violence over exactly how to define the relationship between these three persons.
So eventually, theologians had to invent a doctrine to reconcile the texts, which they legislated into existence at the Council of Nicaea in 325 CE. This was all largely to settle a turf war between rival theological factions. It took another 56 years at Constantinople to work out whether the Holy Spirit was also fully divine or merely a kind of divine intern.
And when pressed, most Christians will just throw up their hands and call it a mystery. God works in mysterious ways, after all, which is theological code for "I know it doesn't make sense, but I've been told to believe it, so I do." Even St. Augustine, one of the greatest theological minds in Christian history, admitted that he couldn't explain it. And if the guy who literally wrote the book on the Trinity can't make it make sense, maybe that's a sign.
3. The Entire Universe Was Built in Less Than a Week
Young Earth creationists believe that God created everything. The Earth, the Sun, the stars, all the plant and animal life, and the entire observable universe, all 93 billion light years of it, in just 6 literal 24-hour days, roughly 6,000 to 10,000 years ago.
To make the math work, young earth creationists have to believe that humans coexisted with dinosaurs, that the Grand Canyon was carved in a few days by Noah's flood, and that light from stars billions of light years away somehow reached Earth in just a few thousand years. Some of them actually argue that God created the light already in transit, which is a fancy way of saying God faked the evidence to make the universe look old, which if true would make God the greatest con artist in cosmic history. And yet somehow he's not the author of confusion.
Meanwhile, we have ice cores, tree rings, radiometric dating, the cosmic microwave background radiation, and about a dozen other independent lines of evidence, all converging on an age of roughly 13.8 billion years for the universe and 4.5 billion for the Earth. But sure, a few thousand years, eh, maybe it's just a rounding error.
4. Everything Was Perfect Until a Talking Snake Ruined Everything
According to Genesis 3, a talking, legged snake persuaded Eve to eat a hunk of fruit. And this single act of horticultural disobedience condemned the entire human race to suffering, death, and the need for salvation. This is the entire foundation of Christian theology, the reason that you need saving. A woman ate a fruit because a snake told her to.
And while some Christians like to say that it is an allegory, if the fall is an allegory, then did Christ die for an allegory, or is he an allegory too? Billions of people across thousands of generations must needlessly suffer because one woman who had been created approximately 5 minutes earlier and had no prior moral education accepted dietary advice from a reptile. That's the doctrine of original sin. You're born broken and there's nothing you can do about it except conveniently join the religion that invented the problem in the first place.
The story also serves conveniently as the foundational justification for the subordination of women, which Paul makes explicitly clear in 1 Timothy, stating that because Eve was deceived, women must remain silent and submissive. And that right there is how a fairy tale turned into a political program, one that continues to operate in evangelical churches today.
5. Demons, Not Germs, Cause Sickness
Throughout the Gospels, Jesus heals people not by treating their medical conditions, but by casting out demons. Epilepsy, demon. Can't speak, demon. Blindness, demon. Mental illness, super demon.
This was relatively unremarkable by the medical standards of first century Palestine, where the germ theory of disease was some 18 centuries away. What is remarkable is that millions of people still believe it today. Pentecostal and charismatic churches across the US and around the world routinely perform exorcisms for conditions like depression, autism, and addiction. There are churches that will openly insist that every mental illness, every sickness, suicide, all of it, is demonic, a spirit hiding inside a person, and that the cure is to command the spirit of autism or any other "mental problem" to leave in Jesus' name.
We know what causes epilepsy. It's abnormal electrical activity in the brain. We can see it on an EEG. If demons were the cause, we wouldn't expect anti-convulsant medication to work, but it does. And yet there are churches right now today where instead of recommending medical care, pastors are screaming at children and disabled people to cast out the demon of cerebral palsy, commanding the "spirit" to come out in the name of Jesus.
6. The Dead Will Physically Come Back to Life
Paul writes in 1 Corinthians 15:52 that the dead will be raised imperishable. Revelation describes a final judgment in which every single corpse is reassembled for divine review. This includes, presumably, people who were cremated, consumed by sharks, or atomized in volcanic eruptions. Every last one of them will somehow be physically reassembled and brought back. People who were buried 50,000 years ago, or whose atoms have been recycled through countless other organisms. People whose ashes were scattered in the ocean where their molecules became part of fish which were then eaten by other people who also died and decomposed.
The logistics of this have plagued the minds of theologians for centuries. Origen asked whether the risen body would include hair and fingernails, which is exactly the sort of question you're reduced to asking when your metaphysics requires the reconstitution of decomposed matter.
What is less often discussed is the sheer moral horror of the accompanying text, which indicates that a significant number of these people who were allegedly resting peacefully will be resurrected just so that they can be condemned to eternal conscious torment, not for any finite crime, but for the sin of insufficient credulity.
7. God Created Languages to Keep a Tower From Reaching Him in Heaven
Genesis 11 tells the story of the Tower of Babel. All of humanity at the time spoke only one language and they decided to come together and build a city with a tower reaching to the heavens. God sees this, apparently feels threatened by a construction project, and scrambles everyone's languages so that they can't cooperate.
Think about that for a second. The all-powerful god of the universe looked down at some bronze age brick layers stacking mud bricks on a ziggurat and thought, "If I don't stop them now, there's no telling what they'll accomplish." This is the same god who supposedly created galaxies, and he's worried about a building. And it's not like we don't have cities with modern buildings significantly higher than ziggurats of the time today, or like we haven't already gone into space and, in the words of Yuri Gagarin, realized that there is no god up there.
Furthermore, we actually have a very good understanding of how languages evolve and diversify. Linguistics can trace language families back thousands of years, and the process is gradual, branching, and driven by migration, isolation, and cultural drift. None of it happened all at once, and none of it started with a building code violation.
Putting It All Together
If you add all of this together, you get a picture of Christianity: a belief that God impregnated a virgin with himself in order to kill himself to save you from himself because he can't just say, "I forgive you." Despite being all powerful, he made rules that he can't bend, you see. And all of this is to punish you for the fruit-eating shenanigans of a dirt man, a rib woman, and a talking snake who you're oh so distantly related to. And unless you believe all of it and eat him in the form of a cracker, you will burn forever... But he "loves" you.
But he can't come down and convince you himself because no one can see God and live, except for Moses who saw him face to face and Jacob who wrestled him and won. And while he could send down his Jesus self, that would trigger the end times, which have been coming any day now for 2,000 years.
If you're a Christian and you're reading this, I know that this probably stings. I spent over two decades of my life believing this stuff. I defended it. I preached it, and I wasn't stupid, and neither are you. These ideas are normalized through repetition, community pressure, and childhood exposure to the point where questioning them feels like you're betraying your family and your friends and your church group. But if these beliefs were presented to you for the first time as an adult without any cultural conditioning, you would laugh the people presenting these ideas out of the room. And that should tell you something.
The most terrifying thing of all of this is that these absurd beliefs are treated in the 21st century as a serious basis for legislation, education policy, and the governance of the most powerful nation on Earth. When a Gallup poll tells you that four in 10 Americans believe that the universe is younger than the domestication of the dog, it stops being charming folklore and it becomes a crisis of reason.
So I'm curious: what are your favorite absurd Christian beliefs and stories?
Get Connected:
New to atheism? I'm here to help.
Enter your email to get my free infographic:
13 Things I Learned in my First Year as an Atheist.
Join our community Facebook group:
Science-loving Skeptics
Join our community of critical thinkers, skeptics, and humanists as we strive to create a better world. We're optimistic about the future, promote science education, and base our understanding of the world on empirical data.